The Third Voice (Music)

 

Beethoven believed that music is the breath of God. A German philosopher once wrote that a life without music would be a mistake. A friend once commented that he had never met a person who did not like music, no matter its form – music is the universal language. Attempting to wrap my mind around this idea, my only conclusion is that all the above musicians, lovers, and thinkers are correct – especially when playing music or writing a song.

Music is not only cerebral but also visceral and a player can remain planted in one of the other.

“Classical” musicians are a perfect example of the cerebral vs. visceral approach to music.

I once listened to a young woman play Chopin (my favorite “Romantic” composer) with nano-second perfection, a display of years of practice and training, but what was lacking was Chopin’s intent, his feeling, his “beautiful sadness” and his subtle nuances of tone and, well, emotion. Though this woman played the piece by note to a specific/perfect time, it lacked, well again, heart. As a musician, listener, I hear this time and again:

“You play the notes but you do not feel the composer’s soul!”

Again, the “head and heart” dilemma: The “right brain” vs. the “left brain.” neurological stance.

The famous 19th-century French composer Satie once had written at the top of his new piano composition: Not to be played with the hands. 

I failed music theory in a big way – too mathematical, too stringent, and too structured.

But, once picking up the guitar, music came easy – I learned the chords and could hear the beat, the tone, and the intent of the song.

Now, when playing with another musician or band, something mystical happens. Our souls tune into each other. And what is most phenomenal, an “ invisible third voice or instrument” joins in on the jam, creating the most perfect sound. If one observes a band carefully, one can see and hear this phenomenon occur – all the musicians look at each other and smile.

To be a truly great musician one should have both theory and heart – and surly that “third voice” will join in, and Beethoven’s “breath of God.” should touch us all.